Personalized medicine’s opportunities and challenges for clinicians, business

Personalized medicine’s opportunities and challenges for clinicians, business

Perhaps the biggest personalized medicine breakthrough of 2011 was the progress of melanoma drug Zelboraf and its companion diagnostic, both of which sped through regulatory approval.

Clinical trials demonstrated that Roche‘s (OTC:RHHBY) Zelboraf was extremely effective in treating skin cancer. But the drug doesn’t work for everyone. Only patients whose tumors express a particular gene mutation respond to the drug. The companion diagnostic also developed by Roche identifies the appropriate patients for Zelboraf. Under priority review by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, approval of that diagnostic was expected this November. The agency beat that target by nearly three months.

Not all personalized medicine drugs and diagnostics will have such a speedy path through the FDA. But the companies, academics and investors who have a stake in personalized medicine are working to smooth the path for future personalized medicine breakthroughs.

The Personalized Medicine Coalition has released a report “The Case for Personalized Medicine,” choosing Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, where the group has a large cluster of members, to formally announce the document. In addition to supporting personalized medicine education and innovation, the group is also pushing for new legislation that would go further than the Genomics and Personalized Medicine Act of 2007. Among the group’s goals are forging a more predictable regulatory path for personalized medicine products and getting Medicare coverage of personalized medicine diagnostics. PMC President Edward Abrahams discusses some of the group’s legislative goals here.

The coalition hosted a panel discussion at the North Carolina Biotechnology Center on the opportunities and challenges facing personalized medicine. Here are some highlights.

Personalized medicine’s promise: In the last quarter, Burlington, North Carolina laboratory services and diagnostics company LabCorp (NYSE:LH) has released two personalized medicine tests, one of them a companion diagnostic for Zelboraf. The other, an Abbott companion diagnostic for lung cancer patients, predicts patient response to the Pfizer (NYSE:PFE) drug Xalkori. LabCorp CEO David King said that at one time, personalized medicine was thought of primarily in terms of reproductive testing such as pre-natal and neo-natal testing. But the technology today has come far and it promises to go even further.

Dr. Amy Abernethy, director of the Duke Cancer Care Research Program, sees many of those tools in the clinic. The kinds of tests that are available for her to use to make diagnostic and treatment decisions are vast and they grow each year. “The way we’ve practiced medicine in the clinic has rocketed forward in the last decade,” Abernethy said.

The challenges: While Abernethy embraces the new diagnostic tools, she said she’s not sure when a new test will show up in an electronic system with a reimbursement code. Jonathan Roy, director of commercial diagnostics for GlaxoSmithKline Biologicals (NYSE:GSK), offered a different perspective on reimbursement. In the United States, a company might get reimbursed, but not at a level they’d like. “In the European market, you might not get reimbursed at all,” he said. Roy said the global regulatory environment is wildly inconsistent from one market to another. But in finding partners for companion diagnostics, GSK must think globally because its goal is to make a test and a treatment available to the largest number of people. LabCorp’s King also sees regulatory as well as cost challenges for companion diagnostics. But as these tests become more common, he also sees challenges for clinicians. Personalized medicine will mean the generation of an enormous amount of data and it will be a challenge to process it and manage it. King likened the challenge to standing on the beach staring at an approaching 60 foot tidal wave. “And there will be one every minute,” he said.

Solutions. There is no shortage of companies angling for financial backing of new therapies and diagnostics in personalized medicine. Durham venture capital firm Pappas Ventures, which focuses on life science investments exclusively, receives more than 1,000 proposals a year. The firm has made several investments in companies developing personalized medicine products. One of them, California biotechnology company Plexxikon, developed the drug that is now Zelboraf. Plexxikon was acquired by Japanese pharma company Daiichi Sankyo earlier this year in a deal valued at more than $935 million. Pappas Ventures saw a return greater than 10 times its original investment in the firm.

Pappas Ventures Managing Partner Eric Linsley said he’s an optimist who believes in personalized medicine. But he added that he’s paid by the firm’s limited partners to be a skeptic. Linsley said he believes solutions will come from innovation. But for that to happen, the FDA must encourage that innovation and payers must modernize how they reimburse new technologies.

CardioDx Passes Trial, Determining When Chest Pain Is No Big Deal

 
November 15, 2011

Chest pain is one of the big reasons people go to the ER or to see their primary care doc. Often when people get there, it’s hard to tell who has serious heart disease or something less serious. Now Palo Alto, CA-based CardioDx is presenting study results that say its new blood test, in certain situations, can help doctors tell the difference.

CardioDx said today that its test, called Corus CAD, was more effective than standard imaging techniques in a study of 537 patients. The study found that the gene expression test, which relies on a blood sample, was better than standard myocardial perfusion imaging (MPI) at ruling out the patients who don’t have coronary artery disease. The results, from a study called Compass, are being presented today at the American Heart Association’s scientific sessions in Orlando, FL.

Epigenetic Therapy Shows Promise in Hard-to-treat Lung Cancer

 
November 9, 2011

PHILADELPHIA — Patients with recurrent metastatic non-small cell lung cancer have a morbid prognosis, but a new epigenetic therapy may have potential for this population, according to data published in Cancer Discovery, a journal of the American Association for Cancer Research.

A research team at Johns Hopkins University tested a combination epigenetic therapy of azacitidine and entinostat among 45 patients with recurrent metastatic non-small cell lung cancer who had been heavily pretreated with other therapies but showed no response. Each patient received azacitidine on nine days and entinostat on two days per month. The trial had an “open-label” design, in which all patients received the treatment and there was no control group receiving a placebo.

Anthera Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (ANTH) Announces Last Patient Enrolled in PEARL-SC Study

HAYWARD, Calif., Oct. 25, 2011 /PRNewswire/ -- Anthera Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (NASDAQ: ANTH), a biopharmaceutical company developing drugs to treat serious diseases associated with inflammation, today announced it has completed enrollment in the Phase 2b PEARL-SC study. PEARL-SC (A randomized, double-blind Phase 2b study to evaluate the efficacy, safety, and tolerability of blisibimod administration in subjects with systemic lupus erythematosus) is examining the therapeutic benefit of weekly and monthly subcutaneous injections of blisibimod in patients with active and antibody positive systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). The targeted number of five hundred and forty (540) patients has been randomized in 11 countries and 72 clinical sites worldwide.

FDA Approves Plexxikon Drug

 
October 18, 2011

Zelboraf, the most-recent Pappas Ventures-backed product to be approved by the FDA, has attracted worldwide media interest. Click here to see the ABC News report on how the melanoma drug, pioneered by Plexxikon, is providing new hope for patients who have this deadly disease.

Plexxikon’s Glaub: personalized medicine is ‘the wave of the future’

 
October 7, 2011

They came from all parts of North Carolina’s Research Triangle, and several of them from far beyond, to hear the story of how a small biotechnology company developed a breakthrough cancer treatment, blazed a path for future development of personalized medicine treatments and was purchased in a deal valued at $935 million — the biggest venture-backed acquisition this year.

The company is California biotech Plexxikon. And one of its investors was Durham, North Carolina-based Pappas Ventures, which saw a return greater than 10 times its original investment. Plexxikon President Kathy Glaub was the guest speaker at a packed house for Pappas Ventures’ annual life sciences symposium. Pappas was one of Plexxikon’s early investors, pumping money into the company shortly after its 2001 launch. Art Pappas, founder and managing partner of the firm, said the investment was as much in founder and CEO Peter Hirth as it was in the science. Pappas said he thought Hirth could do with Plexxikon what he had done with previous company Sugen, whose cancer drug Sutent is now a blockbuster drug for Pfizer (NYSE:PFE).

M&A Still Bright Spot For VCs

The IPO market might be looking a little frosty, but the M&A market so far this year has been positive enough to warm VCs’ hearts.

The median selling price through September was nearly $71 million – four times the median amount invested prior to liquidity, according to Dow Jones VentureSource. That kind of multiple hasn’t been seen since 2000.

Because M&A is affected by the stock market, the pace is likely to fall in the fourth quarter, but the total raised is sure to exceed last year. VentureSource pegs the amount raised in the first nine months at $37.3 billion, only slightly behind the $39.42 billion for all of 2010, which was the best year since 2007. (VentureSource is owned by Dow Jones & Co., the publisher of this blog.)

So far this year, six acquisitions of U.S.-based venture-backed companies have closed at $700 million or more. The biggest was Plexxikon, which Daiichi Sankyo bought for $805 million. The company, which is developing a treatment for melanoma, raised $67 million from investors including Advanced Technology Ventures, Alta Partners, Astellas Venture Capital, Pappas Ventures and Walden International. The deal includes an additional $130 million in potential milestone payments

Second place goes to another health-care company, medical device maker Ardian, which sold to Medtronic for $800 million after raising more than $66 million. Advanced Technology Ventures was an investor in that company, too, along with Emergent Medical Partners, Morgenthaler Ventures and Split Rock Partners. Medtronic also was a backer.

Those deals closed in the first half of the year. The action lately has been more on the tech side. The third-largest deal of the year – and largest of the third quarter – was the $750 million sale of PopCap Games to Electronic Arts. The price could climb by another $550 million if certain performance goals are met. PopCap raised a single round of $22.5 million led by Meritech Capital Partners.

Paul Madera, a Meritech managing director said that during the last two years, the late-stage venture investor has seen its best run of liquidity since its start in 1999. But with stock market volatility crimping IPOs, he expects corporate acquirers to become more cautious. “There isn’t as much urgency to get things done,” Madera said.

Still, large tech companies are sitting on piles of cash and competition is fierce. The most active acquirer through September was Google, which bought nine companies, three of them in the third quarter. Dell and Zynga each have made four acquisitions, tied for second on the list.

Chimerix Announces Late-Breaker Presentation At 51st Interscience Conference On Antimicrobial Agents And Chemotherapy (ICAAC) Annual Meeting

DURHAM, N.C., Sept. 16, 2011 /PRNewswire/ -- Chimerix, Inc., a biotechnology company developing orally-available antiviral therapeutics, announced today that investigators will present preliminary data for CMX001 in a late-breaker presentation at the 51st Annual Interscience Conference on Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy (ICAAC, Chicago – September 17-20).

Syndax Pharmaceutical's Positive Phase 2 Data Supports Potential For Entinostat In Advanced Breast Cancer

WALTHAM, Mass., Sept. 6, 2011 /PRNewswire/ -- Syndax Pharmaceuticals, Inc., a clinical-stage epigenetics oncology company, announced today that ENCORE 301, a randomized, placebo-controlled phase 2 study of exemestane with and without entinostat hit its primary endpoint of an improvement in progression-free survival (PFS).  The study showed that patients who received entinostat, a novel, oral small molecule inhibitor of class I histone deacetylases, with the hormone therapy exemestane, lived longer without their disease getting worse than people who received exemestane alone.   Safety and efficacy results from the trial will be presented in a poster and an oral presentation at the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) Breast Cancer Symposium 2011 in San Francisco, CA this week.

CoLucid Pharmaceuticals Raises $7.5 Million of Planned $9.5 Million

DURHAM, N.C., Aug. 30, 2011 /PRNewswire-iReach/ -- CoLucid Pharmaceuticals, Inc., a privately held biopharmaceutical company, announced today that it has raised $7.5 million of a planned $9.5 million convertible note financing from its existing investors to support further late stage development of lasmiditan.  Participating in the financing were Pappas Ventures, Domain Associates, Care Capital, Pearl Street Venture Funds and Triathlon Medical Ventures.